Where Colin was RIGHT & WRONG: Patriots, Bills, Giants, Chargers, Browns, Vikings | Cowherd HERD NFL

1. Drake Maye's Emerging Talent

Timestamp: 00:00:55 to 00:02:12 - watch this moment on skim

Colin Cowherd argues that Drake Maye's stock is rising, highlighting his strong performance against the Bills, where he outplayed Josh Allen. Cowherd suggests that Maye's ability to use his legs to move the chains, evidenced by eight scrambles, is a key factor in his success. He concludes that Maye is too talented to falter and will ultimately be fine.

Significance (High): Maye's dual-threat ability and poise under pressure suggest he could be a franchise quarterback. His performance challenges traditional evaluations of young QBs.

Sources in support: Colin Cowherd (Host)

Neutral sources: Matt Hasselbeck (Guest Analyst)

2. Josh Allen's Uncharacteristic Struggles

Timestamp: 00:01:33 to 00:02:14 - watch this moment on skim

Cowherd points out Josh Allen's recent struggles, noting his sloppy play, three interceptions in two weeks, and a passer rating lower than Kyler Murray's. He questions whether offensive coordinator Joe Brady is being too permissive, suggesting Allen might benefit from more 'guard rails' from a coach like Sean McDermott. Cowherd concludes that Allen's recent performance is uncharacteristic and concerning.

Significance (High): Allen's dip in performance raises questions about the Bills' offensive consistency and coaching. It highlights the fine line between aggressive play and costly mistakes for star quarterbacks.

Sources in support: Colin Cowherd (Host)

Neutral sources: Matt Hasselbeck (Guest Analyst)

3. Herbert's Struggles and Chargers' Woes

Timestamp: 00:03:09 to 00:03:53 - watch this moment on skim

Cowherd criticizes Justin Herbert's performance, noting his low passer rating and lack of comfort in the offense. He suggests Herbert is part of the problem, forcing passes and struggling to complete them. While acknowledging offensive line issues and injuries, Cowherd concludes that Herbert is not playing up to his potential.

Significance (High): The Chargers' continued struggles with Herbert under center raise serious questions about their offensive direction and coaching. His inability to elevate the team despite talent suggests deeper systemic issues.

Sources in support: Colin Cowherd (Host)

Neutral sources: Matt Hasselbeck (Guest Analyst)

4. Deion Sanders: Recruiter, Not Coach

Timestamp: 00:05:13 to 00:06:02 - watch this moment on skim

Cowherd labels Deion Sanders as an 'anti-Kurt Signetti,' all flash and no substance. He criticizes the team's disorganization and penalties, arguing Sanders excels at recruiting at lower levels but lacks the coaching acumen for major college football. Cowherd concludes Sanders is outclassed as a coach at this level.

Significance (High): Sanders' coaching limitations at the major college level are exposed, suggesting his recruiting prowess doesn't translate to on-field strategy and discipline.

Sources in support: Colin Cowherd (Host)

5. Kalen DeBoer's Coaching Acumen at Alabama

Timestamp: 00:06:02 to 00:07:10 - watch this moment on skim

Cowherd defends Kalen DeBoer, calling him a top-five coach in college football and praising his success at Alabama. He notes DeBoer's ability to succeed despite Alabama's lower NIL money compared to other top programs. Cowherd concludes that DeBoer is an outstanding, world-class coach who will maximize the program's potential.

Significance (High): DeBoer's immediate success at Alabama validates his coaching ability and suggests a smooth transition from Nick Saban. His performance challenges the notion that NIL is the sole determinant of success.

Sources in support: Colin Cowherd (Host)

6. Eagles' Third Down Woes and Hurts' Reluctance to Run

Timestamp: 00:07:34 to 00:09:26 - watch this moment on skim

Matt Hasselbeck discusses the Philadelphia Eagles' struggles on third down, noting their 0-for-12 performance on third downs in a recent game. He suggests Jalen Hurts might be reluctant to run, which he believes Hurts should do when the passing game is struggling. Hasselbeck emphasizes that third downs are 'money downs' and critical for offensive success.

Significance (High): The Eagles' inability to convert on third down is a critical flaw hindering their offense. Hurts' reluctance to use his legs, a key asset, exacerbates these issues.

Sources in support: Matt Hasselbeck (Guest Analyst)

Neutral sources: Colin Cowherd (Host)

7. Bo Nix's Struggles and Broncos' Offensive Imbalance

Timestamp: 00:10:55 to 00:12:58 - watch this moment on skim

Cowherd observes Bo Nix struggling to throw downfield, questioning if it's a solvable issue or a reality. Hasselbeck agrees it looks too hard, comparing Nix unfavorably to Brock Purdy. Both analysts note the Broncos' offensive struggles, with Cowherd suggesting they overcomplicate plays and Hasselbeck advocating for more 'run it' plays instead of excessive pre-snap shifts.

Significance (High): The Broncos' offensive dysfunction, stemming from quarterback struggles and complex play-calling, hinders their ability to execute. This points to a need for simplification and better coordination.

Sources in support: Colin Cowherd (Host), Matt Hasselbeck (Guest Analyst)

8. Raiders' Early Success Built on Leadership and O-Line

Timestamp: 00:13:06 to 00:14:28 - watch this moment on skim

Cowherd praises the Las Vegas Raiders' early success, calling it one of their best losses in a decade. He highlights their focus on improving the offensive line and the leadership of Kirk Cousins and offensive coordinator Clint Kubiak. Cowherd believes the Raiders are 'way ahead of schedule' and starving for relevance.

Significance (High): The Raiders' strategic focus on offensive line and leadership provides a blueprint for rebuilding. Their early success suggests a potential shift in their competitive trajectory.

Sources in support: Colin Cowherd (Host)

Neutral sources: Matt Hasselbeck (Guest Analyst)

9. Seahawks' Creative Offense and Coaching Innovation

Timestamp: 00:16:04 to 00:17:41 - watch this moment on skim

Hasselbeck explains the Seahawks' creative offensive approach, particularly using wide receiver Emanuel Wilson in the run game due to injuries. He praises offensive coordinator Brian Hartline for his innovation and conviction, noting that other NFL teams are now copying Seattle's strategies. Hasselbeck concludes that Hartline's success with various quarterbacks is a testament to his coaching.

Significance (High): Seattle's adaptability and creative play-calling demonstrate effective coaching that can overcome personnel limitations. Their innovative strategies are becoming a model for other teams.

Sources in support: Matt Hasselbeck (Guest Analyst)

Neutral sources: Colin Cowherd (Host)

10. Chargers' Offensive Collapse and Lack of Trust

Timestamp: 00:17:46 to 00:18:39 - watch this moment on skim

Hasselbeck describes the Chargers' offense as 'awful,' citing sloppy play, bad penalties, and a lack of trust among players. He notes that players are doing their own thing out of frustration, which only worsens the situation. Hasselbeck concludes that the team's disarray makes them vulnerable and prone to mistakes.

Significance (High): The Chargers' offensive meltdown points to a severe breakdown in team cohesion and execution. This lack of trust is a critical indicator of deeper organizational issues.

Sources in support: Matt Hasselbeck (Guest Analyst)

Neutral sources: Colin Cowherd (Host)

11. Cowherd: Drake May's Stock Remains Steady

Timestamp: 00:24:36 to 00:27:42 - watch this moment on skim

Colin Cowherd advises against selling Drake May's stock, emphasizing that his struggles are due to a lack of key receivers and offensive line issues, not a fundamental loss of skill. He highlights May's increased rushing attempts and movement as a positive sign, suggesting the Patriots' coaching staff did well to adapt their strategy. Cowherd concludes that May's talent and commitment mean he hasn't forgotten how to play football, and his second-half performance with a 115 passer rating proves the sky isn't falling. The key takeaway is that young quarterbacks can succeed by using their legs when facing adversity. The recipe for struggling quarterbacks is to use their legs, and Drake May did that yesterday. He outplayed Josh Allen yesterday. The sky isn't falling.

Significance (Medium): This point reassures fans and analysts about Drake May's potential, framing his early struggles as typical for a developing quarterback in a challenging environment. It shifts the focus from individual blame to systemic issues and strategic adjustments.

Sources in support: Colin Cowherd (Host)

Neutral sources: Matt Hasselbeck (Guest Analyst)

12. Hasselbeck: Ben Johnson is the Bears' True Centerpiece

Timestamp: 00:27:42 to 00:31:22 - watch this moment on skim

Matt Hasselbeck argues that while quarterbacks are crucial, the true culture builder for teams like the Chiefs with Mahomes or the Lions with Ben Johnson is the coach. He points to the Bears' consistent offensive production, even with backup players, as evidence of Johnson's brilliance. Hasselbeck states that Johnson's scheme allows the team to achieve over 400 yards and dominate time of possession regardless of who is playing quarterback or running back. This offensive dominance, exemplified by 43 minutes of possession time, showcases Johnson's ability to elevate the team, making him the centerpiece of the franchise. The Bears' success is a testament to Ben Johnson's coaching prowess, not just the quarterback.

Significance (High): This highlights a significant shift in football analysis, emphasizing the strategic importance of offensive coordinators. It suggests that a great offensive mind can mitigate quarterback deficiencies and create a sustainable winning culture, challenging the traditional QB-centric view.

Sources in support: Matt Hasselbeck (Guest Analyst)

Neutral sources: Colin Cowherd (Host)

13. Cowherd: Packers' Issues Stem from Coaching

Timestamp: 00:36:06 to 00:37:53 - watch this moment on skim

Colin Cowherd believes the Green Bay Packers' struggles, including penalties and an inability to maintain leads, are directly linked to head coach Matt LaFleur. He compares LaFleur's situation to Lincoln Riley's at USC, suggesting a pattern of soft play and a lack of urgency. Cowherd questions LaFleur's leadership ability to motivate millionaire athletes through tough times, citing dropped passes and missed tackles as evidence. He concludes that while LaFleur is smart offensively, his overall coaching and leadership are holding the team back, making them appear less competitive relative to their talent. The Packers' issues are a reflection of their head coach's leadership.

Significance (High): This point directly criticizes a head coach, raising questions about his long-term viability and the team's future under his leadership. It frames the Packers' performance not as a player issue, but a fundamental coaching deficiency.

Sources in support: Colin Cowherd (Host)

Neutral sources: Jordan Love (Player (Packers Quarterback))

14. Cowherd & Hasselbeck: USC's Defensive Woes and Coaching Questions

Timestamp: 00:39:39 to 00:41:20 - watch this moment on skim

Colin Cowherd and Matt Hasselbeck discuss USC's defensive struggles, particularly their poor tackling, which they deem unacceptable. Cowherd notes that despite having talented players, the team lacks urgency and attention to detail, drawing parallels to the Packers' issues under LaFleur. Hasselbeck points out that USC's defense, despite its talent, is uninspiring and prone to penalties. They question Lincoln Riley's ability to instill discipline and toughness, especially given the fan chants for his dismissal. The discussion highlights that USC's talent level should warrant a higher point spread against Penn State, indicating a disconnect between potential and performance. USC's defensive issues and lack of discipline are a major concern.

Significance (High): This analysis targets a high-profile college program, questioning its coaching and player discipline. It suggests that even with elite recruiting, a lack of fundamental execution and leadership can derail a team's success, impacting fan perception and program trajectory.

Sources in support: Colin Cowherd (Host), Matt Hasselbeck (Guest Analyst)

15. Cowherd: Baseball Playoff Scenarios and Momentum

Timestamp: 00:42:36 to 00:43:56 - watch this moment on skim

Colin Cowherd touches on potential World Series matchups, noting that a Rays vs. Brewers series is possible, which he sees as a win for players in a labor stoppage scenario, implying a salary cap might be beneficial. He questions the concept of momentum in baseball, suggesting it's just a 'next game starting' phenomenon. Cowherd also discusses the Padres' late-inning losses, acknowledging their strong home record but noting Milwaukee's consistency. He believes Milwaukee has more 'swag' and does more things at a high level, making them a formidable opponent. The discussion implies that while individual stars are important, team consistency and overall execution are key in the playoffs. The Padres' late losses are tough, but Milwaukee's season-long consistency gives them an edge.

Significance (Low): This brief segment shifts focus to baseball, offering a perspective on playoff potential and the nature of momentum. It touches on team dynamics and the importance of consistent performance over individual star power, providing a broader sports context.

Sources in support: Colin Cowherd (Host)

Neutral sources: Matt Hasselbeck (Guest Analyst)

16. Cowherd: College Football Needs a Larger Playoff

Timestamp: 00:44:09 to 00:46:06 - watch this moment on skim

Colin Cowherd argues that college football needs a larger playoff system and should move to conference play immediately, eliminating non-competitive 'payout games' against directional schools. He criticizes September football as 'ugly' and lacking compelling matchups, contrasting it with the NFL's immediate high-stakes games. Cowherd believes that good content will always draw viewers, regardless of the day, and that a larger playoff would increase the stakes and excitement throughout the season. He advocates for a system where top conferences play each other, ensuring meaningful games and a more robust playoff structure. The current college football schedule is too diluted with uncompetitive games.

Significance (Medium): This point critiques the structure of the college football season, advocating for significant reform. It suggests that the current system prioritizes tradition over competitive balance and viewer engagement, calling for a playoff expansion and a more streamlined conference schedule.

Sources in support: Colin Cowherd (Host)