Brooklyn coward kills 18 cats, 3 racoons with enough poison to ‘take out an elephant’
"They took matters into their own hands. They took the cheap way out. They took the coward's way out."
- 1. At least 18 cats and three raccoons were callously killed in the mass murder, which has ignited outrage in the Bath Beach neighborhood.
- 2. Albert Berto discovered the horrifying scene last Tuesday morning when he stepped outside to give the 24 cats their daily breakfast — but only one cat rushed to the sound of the shaking food can.
- 3. The NYPD’s Animal Cruelty Investigation Squad and ASPCA are still investigating the cat killing, telling The Post that there have not yet been any arrests.
Article analysis
SKIM this article about "Brooklyn coward kills 18 cats, 3 racoons with enough poison to ‘take out an elephant’": 3 key takeaways and more.
Brooklyn coward kills 18 cats, 3 racoons with enough poison to ‘take out an elephant’
skim AI Analysis | New York Post
New York Post on Brooklyn coward kills 18 cats, 3 racoons with enough poison to ‘take out an elephant’: skim's analysis surfaces 3 key takeaways. A Brooklyn cat colony was poisoned, killing 18 cats and 3 raccoons. Read the takeaways in seconds, then decide whether the full article is worth your time.
Category: Current Events. News article analyzed by skim.
Summary
A Brooklyn cat colony was poisoned, killing 18 cats and 3 raccoons. Caretaker Albert Berto discovered the scene and is devastated. Investigations by the NYPD and ASPCA are ongoing, with activists and local politicians demanding justice.
Key Takeaways
- At least 18 cats and three raccoons were callously killed in the mass murder, which has ignited outrage in the Bath Beach neighborhood.
- Albert Berto discovered the horrifying scene last Tuesday morning when he stepped outside to give the 24 cats their daily breakfast — but only one cat rushed to the sound of the shaking food can.
- The NYPD’s Animal Cruelty Investigation Squad and ASPCA are still investigating the cat killing, telling The Post that there have not yet been any arrests.
Statement Breakdown
- Claimed Facts: 40% of statements the article presents as facts
- Opinions: 45% of statements classified as editorial or subjective
- Claims: 15% of statements surfaced for additional reader evaluation
Credibility & Bias Reasoning
Credibility assessment: The article presents a tragic event with emotional accounts from a caretaker and activist. While it cites investigations by the NYPD and ASPCA, it relies heavily on anecdotal evidence and lacks definitive proof of the perpetrator or the exact cause of death for all animals. The language used is highly charged.
Bias assessment: Sensationalist Outrage. The article employs highly emotional and accusatory language, framing the unknown perpetrator as a 'sadistic creep' and 'coward.' It focuses on generating outrage rather than a neutral presentation of facts, amplifying the caretaker's distress and the perceived injustice.
Note: This article uses strong emotional language and focuses on outrage. While reporting a tragic event, consider that definitive proof of the perpetrator and exact cause for all animals is pending investigation.
Credibility flag: Emotionally Charged Narrative
Claimed Facts (7)
- This states the number of animals killed and the community's reaction as a factual occurrence.
- This describes the caretaker's discovery of the event on a specific day.
- This details the process of discovering the deceased animals over time.
- This states the action taken by the ASPCA and the status of their findings.
- This reports on the ongoing official investigations and the absence of arrests.
- This states the existence of a petition and political pressure as factual events.
- This provides factual information about the legal penalties for animal poisoning.
Opinions (8)
- The term 'sadistic creep' is an opinion and an accusation, not a proven fact.
- This expresses the caretaker's personal feelings and beliefs about the animals' suffering.
- This describes the caretaker's personal emotional and physical distress.
- While Berto suspected poisoning, the certainty and the method are presented as his immediate conclusion.
- While Berto quotes a toxicology report, the interpretation and comparison to an elephant's death is a subjective framing.
- This states the belief of Berto and neighbors, which is an opinion and not a confirmed fact about the perpetrator's identity or motives.
- This is a strong judgment and opinion on the perpetrator's actions and character.
- This expresses the assemblyman's personal hope and desire for justice.
Claims (5)
- The term 'sadistic creep' is highly charged and accusatory without evidence, and the quantity of poison is presented as an extreme, potentially exaggerated comparison.
- This is a vague attribution ('the toxicology guy') and a dramatic comparison that lacks specific scientific context or verification within the article.
- This presents a belief as a strong possibility without providing concrete evidence of the perpetrator's identity or their direct admission of hate or motive.
- While outrage may exist, attributing it solely to 'lack of accountability' is an interpretation and potentially an overstatement of the community's unified sentiment.
- While there are laws protecting animals, the specific application and protection status of 'stray' or 'community' cats under these laws requires more detailed legal context than provided.
Key Sources
- Katherine Donlevy — Author
- Albert Berto — Caretaker
- Reeva Grammatikopoulos — Wildlife activist
- William Colton — Assemblyman
- NYPD — Law Enforcement
- ASPCA — Animal Welfare Organization
This analysis was generated by skim (skim.plus), an AI-powered content analysis platform by Credible AI. Scores and classifications represent the platform's AI-generated assessment and should be considered alongside other sources.
skim analyzes recent New York Post coverage for what holds up, what reads as opinion, and what may not be fully supported. Last updated 16th September 2026.